'
Case Study ● Angela Caglia

How Angela Caglia Stood Out in Beauty

177

‍

Variations

‍

25%

‍

Lower CPA

84%

‍

Best Ad

The challenge

In the sprawling landscape of beauty, Angela Caglia faced the monumental challenge of breaking through a cluttered industry. 

The brand's mission was to redefine beauty routines by introducing high-quality, luxurious skincare products based on science. The beauty market, however, is teeming with a continuous influx of new products. Angela Caglia needed to differentiate themselves with a strategy that would allow them to convey the differences in their products in short ad formats.

The solution

Pencil AI became Angela Caglia’s canvas for experimentation, enabling them to test various ad iterations and seek audience feedback on different aspects of their skincare products. Pencil makes it easy to test and tweak creatives at lightning speed

The results

Angela Caglia ended up testing 177 creatives before they found ones that cut through the noise. Using Pencil to find high-performing ads swiftly saves time, money and a ton of faff.

Rob Carliner (co-founder, Angela Caglia) put it this way: “Pencil eliminates the guesswork in making winning ad creatives. The interface is easy, the results impressive. Lots of companies claim to have built a better mousetrap - Pencil has actually done it!”

‍

Articles

Lounge Lovers turned 300 furniture shoots into 1 workflow
Article

Lounge Lovers turned 300 furniture shoots into 1 workflow

300 production-ready images across 5 furniture categories, made in 6 weeks.

Pencil vs WPP Open (2026)
Article

Pencil vs WPP Open (2026)

Both cover the workflow. The difference is how you buy it and what you can check.

Pencil vs Smartly (2026)
Article

Pencil vs Smartly (2026)

Smartly starts at production and media. Pencil starts earlier, at strategy.

Pencil vs Celtra (2026)
Article

Pencil vs Celtra (2026)

Celtra starts at production. Pencil starts at strategy and runs to results.